FidoNet Echomail Archive
r_catholic

<<< Previous Index Next >>>

From: Joseph Meehan
To: CE
Date: 2007-04-01 13:09:54
Subject: Re: Catholic Women: Rocking the Boat

From: "Joseph Meehan" <sligoNoSPAMjoe{at}hotmail.com>

CE wrote:
> On Apr 1, 7:38 am, "Joseph Meehan"
<sligoNoSPAM...{at}hotmail.com> wrote:
>> CE wrote:
>>> On Mar 31, 1:56 pm, "Joseph Meehan"
<sligoNoSPAM...{at}hotmail.com>
>>> wrote:
>>
>>> <snip>
>>
>>>>     Illogical argument.  A+B does not equal C
>>
>>> Okay, I'll bite. Why fp you think it was an illogical argument?
>>
>>     (A) Priest take a vow of obedience when ordained.
>>
>>     (B) A woman allowing one's self to be ordained would violate
>> that vow.
>>
>>     Those we agree with. But you also need this one:
>>
>>     (C) Breaking a vow invalidates the ordination.
>>
>>     If that were true then we would truly have very few priest.
>> Priest are human just like the rest of us.  We all sin.
>>
>>     For your logic to make sense A, B & C must all be true.
>>
>
> They are all true.

    Could you provide a reference for your statement that "(C) Breaking a
vow invalidates the ordination" is true?

--
Joseph Meehan

 Dia 's Muire duit

--- BBBS/LiI v4.01 Flag
 * Origin: Prism bbs (1:261/38)
SEEN-BY: 633/267 5030/786
@PATH: 261/38 123/500 379/1 633/267


<<< Previous Index Next >>>